A pleasantly modernized Damn Yankees! hits the stage at the Ordway
 |
| Photo courtesy of the Ordway. |
It’s always nice to see stories evolve.
In the musical world, it can be easy to get stuck in the ‘golden age’ of Hollywood, where everything was squeaky clean and hunky dory, and the messier sides of life in America were swept neatly behind the figurative overstuffed davenport.
Thankfully, the new production of rarely performed Damn Yankees! at the Ordway does not fall prey to such a trap. While the story retains its wholesome plotline, innovative casting and a cast clearly enjoying themselves sweep the dust off.
For those uninitiated, Damn Yankees! follows a middle aged man named Joe who is the biggest fan of the Washington Senators. Disappointed with their poor performance and consistent losses to the Yankees, he makes a deal with Mr. Applegate, the devil’s right hand man, to be transformed into a the world’s best baseball player in order to lead his team to victory.
 |
| Photo courtesy of the Ordway. |
The only problem is that he misses his wife and home – a lot. Too much. Joe succeeds in helping the Senators win the pennant, but resists all temptation (including a tailor made temptress named Lola) of fame and the trappings that go with it to return to his wife and cozy home.
Lawrence Clayton and Thay Floyd are excellent as the old and young Joe, respectively. They are eerily well paired physically and sonically, and both feature gorgeous voices with a great range of expression. They’re Broadway transplants, and it shows; I wish they were sticking around for more local productions.
The rest of the cast is less excellent but holds their own. Ann Morrison is sweet as Joe’s lonely wife Meg; Kersten Rodau brings her signature spunk to reporter Gloria Thorpe; Allen Fitzpatrick is loveably gruff as the Senator’s coach Van Buren; and Monte Riegel Wheeler is delightfully flamboyant as the devious Mr. Applegate.
 |
| Photo courtesy of the Ordway. |
It’s worth noting here that subtle casting choices can make a break or show; they certainly elevated this one. It was refreshing to see Meg and Joe’s relationship be interracial (more of that please!), and Mr. Applegate portrayed with a more complex sexuality than a 1950’s audience would have preferred. Small details like this made the show feel modern, and certainly strayed from St. Paul’s stiff-upper-lip, white class reputation. I’d love to see this continue in future productions.
 |
| Photo courtesy of the Ordway. |
Damn Yankees! is no Bernstein masterpiece, but it’s a fun show all the same. It’s nice to see it getting some attention, and to see the casting choices reflect modern life. More productions could stand to cast the best people for their roles, instead of the most “historical” choice. Damn Yankees! runs through June 28, 2015; make sure you check it out if you get a chance!